Jalopy Talk readers have been voting on old cars: a heart or a thumbs-down under every photo in our car articles, from 1960s muscle cars and station wagons to the crossovers nobody bought. We’ve pulled it all into one report: 16,705 votes from 3,978 readers on 527 car models and hundreds of dashboards, gas stations, drive-ins and driving habits, plus 5,682 answers to our car polls.
Please note that some of the images in this article were created with the assistance of AI.
The short version: readers love the old metal. 77% of all votes were hearts. But not every era made it.
The golden age runs to the 1960s

Car models from the 1940s to the 1960s drew 83% to 87% hearts. Every later decade scores lower, and the 2000s and the 2010s are the low point (47% and 48%), too close to call between them. Some of our articles are friendlier than others, so we also compared each decade with the average of the articles its cars appeared in. The pattern held: the 1940s came out strongest and the 2000s weakest.
Muscle cars and station wagons win; SUVs and crossovers and minivans lose

Muscle cars (84%), station wagons (84%) and sports cars (78%) lead. SUVs and crossovers (49%) and minivans (57%) sit at the bottom. Japanese models drew 56% hearts, against 72% for American and 72% for European cars.
The cars readers love most, and least


At the top: Austin-Healey Sprite (100%), 2005 Ford GT (100%), Volkswagen Karmann Ghia (100%). At the bottom: SsangYong Rodius (0%), Subaru B9 Tribeca (0%), Second-Generation Ford Taurus (5%). With small vote counts per car, those ends of the list are groups rather than an exact order. When readers gave a reason for a thumbs-down, “Not my style” (32%), “Don’t like the shape” (17%), “Looks dated” (12%) came first; after a heart, “Brings back memories” (19%), “The body style” (16%), “I’d drive one today” (16%).
The polls point the same way: 54% of readers picked the 1950s over the 1970s and today as the best-looking car era, 73% prefer lots of chrome to a clean look, and 61% say good riddance to the 1970s vinyl roof.
The photos readers loved most
Backing Off the Gas When the Rain Comes Down Hard
Vent Windows: Fingertip Air Conditioning Before Climate Control
Alpine A-Frame Ski Lodge with a Hot-Tub Roof Deck
Letting Aggressive Drivers Pass
Austin-Healey Sprite: The Original Bugeye Grin
Color Palette That Assumed You Wanted People to See You Coming
And the ones they rejected
SsangYong Rodius: Conflicting Rooflines That Never Reconciled
Subaru B9 Tribeca: A Grille Fashion That Overpowered the Whole Car
Pontiac Aztek: Trend Forecasting Still Could Not Create Beauty
Second-Generation Ford Taurus: Rounded Innovation That Became a Time…
Cadillac Cimarron: Economy-Car Bones Exposed by Luxury Trim
Second-Generation Toyota Prius: A Futuristic Profile Turned Period…
The full report
The Classic Car Report scores all 527 car models (the ranked list is in the dataset), breaks them down by decade, body style and origin, shows which cars aged well and which flops readers forgive, and adds why readers loved or rejected each car and 5,682 poll answers. It includes the full dataset.
Get the full report at StatwrenHow we did this
- Readers tapped a heart or a thumbs-down under each photo in our car articles between Aug 31, 2026 and Nov 17, 2026. One vote per reader per photo.
- Votes are anonymous: no names, emails or accounts. Readers were reacting to photos of each car, not driving it.
- Percentages are the share of hearts. Decade, body style and origin are our own tags for each model.
- More on how we collect reader data: How our reader data works.
